FREE COMPULSORY EDUCATION
© Chippy's Dad
I will start this post with several assertions with which I believe most people will agree. Education is a good that enables persons to live more successfully. We are all better off if everyone is well educated. Education is expensive. Education takes time. A person's education is never complete; there is always more to learn.
Assuming the foregoing assertions to be true, is compulsion acceptable to extend education to a maximum number of people? For reasons discussed below, compulsion is not okay. Is the use of tax dollars to provide an education at no cost or reduced cost to the student acceptable? No-cost or subsidized education is neither acceptable nor beneficial.
NO-COST EDUCATION
Imagine a caller uses the phone to initiate an offer for a free service, say a free home pest inspection. Such an inspection requires entry into the home by an unknown person. Unless a person is both concerned about pests and has reason to believe the caller represents a legitimate business, she would be likely to turn down the offer. The reason for turning down the offer involves consideration of the alternative outcomes from accepting the offer which outcomes could include:
• Pests are found and a reasonable offer is made to eliminate the pests.
• Pests are found and an unreasonably expensive offer for pest control is made.
• Pests are reported to exist when in fact they do not, and an offer is made to eliminate them.
• The inspector cases the house and returns to burglarize the house.
Considering the alternatives, the offer is rejected because the offer of a free service makes the service appear to have no real value and may indeed be of negative value.
A child very quickly learns that free services usually result in a waste of time. A free internet web site requires spending time listening to advertisements. Purchasing an item so advertised often results in receiving an item that is a waste of money. The example actually appears to have the same form as no-cost education: a "teacher" is informing, i.e. lecturing, the student of certain "facts" for free.
When education is offered for free, the offer suggests that education has no value. The people offering the education may have an agenda that is in the best interest of the people making the offer, not the student. An offer of education for free reduces the investment required of the student. Based on experience, the student rightly thinks that you get what you pay for. The student is likely to make the jump to the idea that pursuing any education is a waste of time.
COMPULSION
Imagine a child wants to go outside and play. His father forces him to wash the car first. A child quickly learns that whatever is forced upon him is undesirable. No force is required to make him play outside. Force is required to make him wash the car. From this lesson when compulsion is used to force a student to learn, the student is likely to make the jump to the idea that pursuing an education should be resisted.
THE TWO LAWS
A free tax-supported compulsory education violates the first of the two laws. HONOR THE LIFE AND PROPERTY OF OTHER PEOPLE. The law is violated because the requirement under pain of sanction to attend a school aggresses against the student by denying her right to freedom. It aggresses against the tax payer by forcefully taking property to support an educational establishment. The aggression is even more damaging if the taxpayer opposes the particular educational environment and doctrines subsidized by the tax.
ACHIEVING AN EDUCATION
The essential ingredient for a person to achieve an education is personal desire and commitment. No-cost compulsory education works on two levels to reduce the educational level of people by reducing both the desire and the commitment of the student. In any case, violation of the person through the use of force is never acceptable, even for a most noble cause. In order to improve the educational standards of a society, all education must be free of all compulsion and must reflect to the student the true cost. Only education achieved in spite of great obstacles will instill education with the meaning to the student that leads to greatness.
Showing posts with label two laws. Show all posts
Showing posts with label two laws. Show all posts
Wednesday, August 4, 2010
Tuesday, July 27, 2010
TOWARDS A PHILOSOPHY OF LAW
TOWARDS A PHILOSOPHY OF LAW
©Chippy's Dad
What Is Law? Much confusion surrounds the term "law". As commonly used, it refers to at least four separate concepts including the law of God, scientific law, moral law, and legislation. The concepts represented by the first three expressions of law precede the actions of men; these laws are not man-made. Legislation is man-made.
Divine law, scientific law, and moral law constitute human being's attempts to understand and articulate the reality of creation: the universe in which people live. They represent truth to the human capacity for understanding. To the extent of current understanding, these laws never contradict each other. When a contradiction is found, the need for more reflection on the milieu of human existence is indicated. After finding a firm ground upon which to stand, individuals acting alone or in community can hypothesize and test revised understandings. Whatever these understandings, the basic reality remains unchanged and completely in operation.
DIVINE LAW is expressed in the writings, creeds, authorities, and sacraments of the gathering: mosque, synagogue, church. The content of divine law relates to the relationship between mankind and God. Divine law is different from other law because it represents the intentionality of God as far as humans can understand it. All religious expressions contain some version of two laws which precede the actions of people:
HONOR THE LIFE AND PROPERTY OF OTHER PEOPLE.
ABIDE BY YOUR COMMITMENTS.
SCIENTIFIC LAW is expressed in various scientific theories. The content relates to observed natural relationships. An example of scientific law is the law of supply and demand as described by students of economics. Scientific law is different from divine law and legislation because it does not represent intentionality. For example the law of supply and demand is not intended to achieve any purpose other than to explain our observations of economic activity and results. It is not used as an attempt to create a level playing field nor make a group of people wealthier. It merely explains how the world works.
Another scientific law is the second law of thermal dynamics which is not intended to achieve a particular state of affairs but explains that entropy increases. In short all things rundown or wear out.
Leaders in government attempt to achieve certain economic results; but if in so doing, they disregard the scientific law of supply and demand, the results will be disappointing at best. In a like manner many people have denied the second law of thermal dynamics and have wasted much time and resources trying to develop a perpetual motion machine through which energy can be extracted from the machine without putting energy into the machine. Indeed, the concept of the government spending our way into prosperity is an example of a perpetual motion machine. Supposedly, we can extract resources from the economy without first putting energy into the economy.
MORAL LAW is expressed in moral philosophical investigations. The content relates to the civil relations between humans. A central precept of moral law is the categorical imperative, which has been stated in many ways:
1. "Love your neighbor as yourself." –Jesus
2. "So act that you can will that the maxim of your action to be a universal law." –Kant
3. "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal; that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights; that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness." –Jefferson
Like scientific law, moral law does not represent intentionality. Moral law consists of a-priori statements of mandates to explain the nature of relations between people and which precede any human intentions.
An example of moral law is the prohibition against stealing. The prohibition is implied by the first law listed above. Failure to abide by the prohibition against stealing results in a loss to the community of all humans. It results in a larger loss than the loss to the victim of theft.
Once upon a time, in Memphis, I observed the attempted theft of an auto battery. In what was probably not the wisest move, I came up and stood beside the would-be thief without him noticing my presence and quietly asked what was wrong with his car. (It happened that I knew both the thief and the owner of the car.) He was completely surprised and immediately stood up straight, looked at me with extreme fear written on his face, and ran away. I closed the hood and reported the situation to the owner. It is probably a vain hope, but I do hope it put such fear in the thief that he never stole again.
The point of the story is to imagine what would have happened had he stolen the battery. The thief would have sold the battery for a buck or two. The battery would then have been resold for some price less than the price of a new battery. Meanwhile, the owner of the car would have been denied the use of her car. As it was, the battery was disconnected and she had to have a friend reconnect it. She would have had to take the time to figure out why her car would not start, call the police to report the theft, go to a battery store, buy a replacement battery, and have it installed. The costs across the entire community in time and effort would have been several hundred dollars expended in order that the thief could have gained maybe two dollars. Time and effort would have been wasted trying to restore a previous situation as opposed to advancing to an improved situation. The largest loss in the preceding example is the loss of trust. People find it necessary to lock doors, install antitheft devices, and hire security guards.
The same applies to taxes. The government receives its money. In order for that to happen, it must employ a hoard of tax collectors. People must employ highly trained experts to decipher the byzantine tax code. People must invest their savings in less than ideal (but government favored) ventures in order to maximize their after tax savings. The loss to the community in time and resources far exceeds the resources available for government expenditures. The biggest loss to the community as a whole is the loss confidence. Everyone lives in fear because no one can be sure that they can avoid an audit by a harassing bureaucrat, be found in "violation" of some obscure provision, and fined or imprisoned.
The moral law prohibiting theft precedes action by mankind and reflects the reality that healthy relationships among people suffer whenever the principle is violated.
All of the preceding forms of law are operational at all times and do not in any way require enforcement. Violations of them always produce unpleasant, and usually immediate, results.
LEGISLATION is expressed in the acts of governments. I try to reserve the term "law" to the above three expressions of law. References to legislation should avoid the term "law". Law precedes the action of people; legislation does not. The distinction between law and legislation implies that legislation can and frequently does contradict expressions of law.
For example in Germany of the 1930's and early 1940's it was illegal and a capital offence to harbor people of the Jewish faith. This legislation contradicts both divine and moral law. The losses to the community of people in Germany and throughout the world were beyond calculation. Germany for a short period reverted to the stone-age. Never-the-less, the policy of harassing Jews was exceedingly popular just as harassing undocumented immigrants is today.
In the same way it is supposedly "illegal" in the United States to harbor or employ undocumented aliens. Clearly this legislation is illegal since it contradicts the natural prohibition of encroachment and the unalienable right to liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Refer to the previous post on this site On Immigration. The cost to the community of humans is incalculable. Those who are so vocal about "illegal" immigrants should consider the cost of deporting in excess of seven million people. Such a mass deportation would create massive hardship and would rank among the largest forced migrations in history. It would exceed the Trail of Tears.
Much legislation is acceptable. For example, the requirement to drive on the right side of the road establishes a convention to enable safe driving. The convention does not violate the Laws. However, most legislation does violate the laws. All legislation that violates the laws will produce unpleasant results. Unpleasant results include injuries, financial chaos, loss of healthy relationships, starvation, poverty, and death.
©Chippy's Dad
What Is Law? Much confusion surrounds the term "law". As commonly used, it refers to at least four separate concepts including the law of God, scientific law, moral law, and legislation. The concepts represented by the first three expressions of law precede the actions of men; these laws are not man-made. Legislation is man-made.
Divine law, scientific law, and moral law constitute human being's attempts to understand and articulate the reality of creation: the universe in which people live. They represent truth to the human capacity for understanding. To the extent of current understanding, these laws never contradict each other. When a contradiction is found, the need for more reflection on the milieu of human existence is indicated. After finding a firm ground upon which to stand, individuals acting alone or in community can hypothesize and test revised understandings. Whatever these understandings, the basic reality remains unchanged and completely in operation.
DIVINE LAW is expressed in the writings, creeds, authorities, and sacraments of the gathering: mosque, synagogue, church. The content of divine law relates to the relationship between mankind and God. Divine law is different from other law because it represents the intentionality of God as far as humans can understand it. All religious expressions contain some version of two laws which precede the actions of people:
HONOR THE LIFE AND PROPERTY OF OTHER PEOPLE.
ABIDE BY YOUR COMMITMENTS.
SCIENTIFIC LAW is expressed in various scientific theories. The content relates to observed natural relationships. An example of scientific law is the law of supply and demand as described by students of economics. Scientific law is different from divine law and legislation because it does not represent intentionality. For example the law of supply and demand is not intended to achieve any purpose other than to explain our observations of economic activity and results. It is not used as an attempt to create a level playing field nor make a group of people wealthier. It merely explains how the world works.
Another scientific law is the second law of thermal dynamics which is not intended to achieve a particular state of affairs but explains that entropy increases. In short all things rundown or wear out.
Leaders in government attempt to achieve certain economic results; but if in so doing, they disregard the scientific law of supply and demand, the results will be disappointing at best. In a like manner many people have denied the second law of thermal dynamics and have wasted much time and resources trying to develop a perpetual motion machine through which energy can be extracted from the machine without putting energy into the machine. Indeed, the concept of the government spending our way into prosperity is an example of a perpetual motion machine. Supposedly, we can extract resources from the economy without first putting energy into the economy.
MORAL LAW is expressed in moral philosophical investigations. The content relates to the civil relations between humans. A central precept of moral law is the categorical imperative, which has been stated in many ways:
1. "Love your neighbor as yourself." –Jesus
2. "So act that you can will that the maxim of your action to be a universal law." –Kant
3. "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal; that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights; that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness." –Jefferson
Like scientific law, moral law does not represent intentionality. Moral law consists of a-priori statements of mandates to explain the nature of relations between people and which precede any human intentions.
An example of moral law is the prohibition against stealing. The prohibition is implied by the first law listed above. Failure to abide by the prohibition against stealing results in a loss to the community of all humans. It results in a larger loss than the loss to the victim of theft.
Once upon a time, in Memphis, I observed the attempted theft of an auto battery. In what was probably not the wisest move, I came up and stood beside the would-be thief without him noticing my presence and quietly asked what was wrong with his car. (It happened that I knew both the thief and the owner of the car.) He was completely surprised and immediately stood up straight, looked at me with extreme fear written on his face, and ran away. I closed the hood and reported the situation to the owner. It is probably a vain hope, but I do hope it put such fear in the thief that he never stole again.
The point of the story is to imagine what would have happened had he stolen the battery. The thief would have sold the battery for a buck or two. The battery would then have been resold for some price less than the price of a new battery. Meanwhile, the owner of the car would have been denied the use of her car. As it was, the battery was disconnected and she had to have a friend reconnect it. She would have had to take the time to figure out why her car would not start, call the police to report the theft, go to a battery store, buy a replacement battery, and have it installed. The costs across the entire community in time and effort would have been several hundred dollars expended in order that the thief could have gained maybe two dollars. Time and effort would have been wasted trying to restore a previous situation as opposed to advancing to an improved situation. The largest loss in the preceding example is the loss of trust. People find it necessary to lock doors, install antitheft devices, and hire security guards.
The same applies to taxes. The government receives its money. In order for that to happen, it must employ a hoard of tax collectors. People must employ highly trained experts to decipher the byzantine tax code. People must invest their savings in less than ideal (but government favored) ventures in order to maximize their after tax savings. The loss to the community in time and resources far exceeds the resources available for government expenditures. The biggest loss to the community as a whole is the loss confidence. Everyone lives in fear because no one can be sure that they can avoid an audit by a harassing bureaucrat, be found in "violation" of some obscure provision, and fined or imprisoned.
The moral law prohibiting theft precedes action by mankind and reflects the reality that healthy relationships among people suffer whenever the principle is violated.
All of the preceding forms of law are operational at all times and do not in any way require enforcement. Violations of them always produce unpleasant, and usually immediate, results.
LEGISLATION is expressed in the acts of governments. I try to reserve the term "law" to the above three expressions of law. References to legislation should avoid the term "law". Law precedes the action of people; legislation does not. The distinction between law and legislation implies that legislation can and frequently does contradict expressions of law.
For example in Germany of the 1930's and early 1940's it was illegal and a capital offence to harbor people of the Jewish faith. This legislation contradicts both divine and moral law. The losses to the community of people in Germany and throughout the world were beyond calculation. Germany for a short period reverted to the stone-age. Never-the-less, the policy of harassing Jews was exceedingly popular just as harassing undocumented immigrants is today.
In the same way it is supposedly "illegal" in the United States to harbor or employ undocumented aliens. Clearly this legislation is illegal since it contradicts the natural prohibition of encroachment and the unalienable right to liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Refer to the previous post on this site On Immigration. The cost to the community of humans is incalculable. Those who are so vocal about "illegal" immigrants should consider the cost of deporting in excess of seven million people. Such a mass deportation would create massive hardship and would rank among the largest forced migrations in history. It would exceed the Trail of Tears.
Much legislation is acceptable. For example, the requirement to drive on the right side of the road establishes a convention to enable safe driving. The convention does not violate the Laws. However, most legislation does violate the laws. All legislation that violates the laws will produce unpleasant results. Unpleasant results include injuries, financial chaos, loss of healthy relationships, starvation, poverty, and death.
Labels:
categorical imperative,
holocaust,
immigration,
law,
scientific law,
two laws
Monday, July 12, 2010
ON JUST GOVERNMENT
ON JUST GOVERNMENT
©Chippy's Dad
The LAW precedes all government. My views on government start with my dedication to Jesus and the Christian God. Based on my faith, all law can be boiled down to 2 basic laws that precede all others and that precede man made government. (I note that other people with similar views on just government start with an atheistic or even an agnostic faith, to wit: Ludwig VonMises, Doug Casey.)
THE TWO LAWS:
1. HONOR THE LIFE AND PROPERTY OF OTHER PEOPLE (1).
2. ABIDE BY YOUR COMMITMENTS (2).
The problem for just government resides in the fact that people are greedy. In particular, some people are greedy for power. When that power manifests itself in the form of power over other people, the first law is violated. Since people with a greed for power over people tend towards government office, where they can satisfy their craving; government necessarily tends towards injustice.
People who lust for power over other people see an opportunity in civil government to realize their goals. Government is a technology or tool for the domination of people. As long as there are greedy people, government will tend towards tyranny.
The founders of the USA tried twice (the Articles and the Constitution) to develop a government that would be limited so that greedy people could not become tyrants. From day one, the government of the USA has become ever more militaristic and tyrannical, gradually and continuously, until the life blood has been sapped from the very marrow of our community.
From the militaristic point of view, first the greedy ones launched an ill-fated invasion of Canada. To follow on, they subjugated the Native Americans and attacked Mexico in order to take possession of Texas and California. Then they expanded overseas by overthrowing the government of Hawaii in 1893, by attacking and annexing certain territories of Spain in 1898, by attacking independence minded Filipinos in 1899, by participating in WW1 and the Versailles Treaty, etc., etc. In the twentieth century, overseas military adventures became too numerous to list.
From the tyrannical point of view, the early history is complex beyond the scope of this post but a major turning point was the year 1913. In that year, the income tax was established, the direct election of senators was established, and the Federal Reserve was established. The income tax gave the greedy ones in the central government direct knowledge and control over individual Americans and their finances. The direct election of senators assaulted the sovereignty of the states by removing the one strong control the states had over the central government after their right to withdraw from the union had been eliminated by the War of Northern Aggression otherwise known as the Civil War. The Federal Reserve socialized money. With socialized money, the government of the USA rejected the free market. The Federal Reserve has provided the greedy ones with the ability expand the scope of the government for intrusion into the lives of Americans almost beyond limit. Since we live under socialized money, what market freedom remains is severely degraded and has become ever more degraded since 1913.
The Constitution has been interpreted gradually until constitutional limits no longer apply. Who is doing this interpretation? Why those people in Washington who are greedy for power; that is who. These people have a deep seated conflict of interest. They each have a personal interest in increasing their own power.
One way that might have provided for a more just government (maybe) would have been to include in the Constitution an explicit provision that, as sovereign entities, states can withdraw from the union. More importantly, a provision should have been included that, as sovereign entities, individual citizens can withdraw from participation in the government. Such an individual could live, travel, and hold property in the USA without harassment; would pay no taxes; would be subject to no restrictions other than to conform to the two laws; but would not be eligible to stand for public office; or to vote; or to receive any service offered by the government, such as fire fighting, without paying a fee. Individuals who have withdrawn would be free to form associations to provide alternative services such as fire fighting.
The two provisions allowing secession of states and individuals, respectively, would enhance just government in that as the government tends towards increased tyranny, which it must because of the greedy ones, individuals would withdraw. As the numbers of individuals who have withdrawn increases, the greedy ones would have ever less power. In their own greedy interest, the greedy ones would need to leave more liberties to the people, so that they would want to participate in the government.
This concept becomes the definition of just government. A just government is one that subjects itself and its agents to the two fundamental laws and that allows citizens and provinces to secede from the government without loss of personal freedoms or property.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
(1) The first law has been stated: "Love your neighbor as yourself." – Jesus, and also "Act only according to that maxim whereby you can at the same time will that it should become a universal law."– Lock
(2) The second law has been stated: "Thou shalt not bear false witness." - Exodus 20:16.
©Chippy's Dad
The LAW precedes all government. My views on government start with my dedication to Jesus and the Christian God. Based on my faith, all law can be boiled down to 2 basic laws that precede all others and that precede man made government. (I note that other people with similar views on just government start with an atheistic or even an agnostic faith, to wit: Ludwig VonMises, Doug Casey.)
THE TWO LAWS:
1. HONOR THE LIFE AND PROPERTY OF OTHER PEOPLE (1).
2. ABIDE BY YOUR COMMITMENTS (2).
The problem for just government resides in the fact that people are greedy. In particular, some people are greedy for power. When that power manifests itself in the form of power over other people, the first law is violated. Since people with a greed for power over people tend towards government office, where they can satisfy their craving; government necessarily tends towards injustice.
People who lust for power over other people see an opportunity in civil government to realize their goals. Government is a technology or tool for the domination of people. As long as there are greedy people, government will tend towards tyranny.
The founders of the USA tried twice (the Articles and the Constitution) to develop a government that would be limited so that greedy people could not become tyrants. From day one, the government of the USA has become ever more militaristic and tyrannical, gradually and continuously, until the life blood has been sapped from the very marrow of our community.
From the militaristic point of view, first the greedy ones launched an ill-fated invasion of Canada. To follow on, they subjugated the Native Americans and attacked Mexico in order to take possession of Texas and California. Then they expanded overseas by overthrowing the government of Hawaii in 1893, by attacking and annexing certain territories of Spain in 1898, by attacking independence minded Filipinos in 1899, by participating in WW1 and the Versailles Treaty, etc., etc. In the twentieth century, overseas military adventures became too numerous to list.
From the tyrannical point of view, the early history is complex beyond the scope of this post but a major turning point was the year 1913. In that year, the income tax was established, the direct election of senators was established, and the Federal Reserve was established. The income tax gave the greedy ones in the central government direct knowledge and control over individual Americans and their finances. The direct election of senators assaulted the sovereignty of the states by removing the one strong control the states had over the central government after their right to withdraw from the union had been eliminated by the War of Northern Aggression otherwise known as the Civil War. The Federal Reserve socialized money. With socialized money, the government of the USA rejected the free market. The Federal Reserve has provided the greedy ones with the ability expand the scope of the government for intrusion into the lives of Americans almost beyond limit. Since we live under socialized money, what market freedom remains is severely degraded and has become ever more degraded since 1913.
The Constitution has been interpreted gradually until constitutional limits no longer apply. Who is doing this interpretation? Why those people in Washington who are greedy for power; that is who. These people have a deep seated conflict of interest. They each have a personal interest in increasing their own power.
One way that might have provided for a more just government (maybe) would have been to include in the Constitution an explicit provision that, as sovereign entities, states can withdraw from the union. More importantly, a provision should have been included that, as sovereign entities, individual citizens can withdraw from participation in the government. Such an individual could live, travel, and hold property in the USA without harassment; would pay no taxes; would be subject to no restrictions other than to conform to the two laws; but would not be eligible to stand for public office; or to vote; or to receive any service offered by the government, such as fire fighting, without paying a fee. Individuals who have withdrawn would be free to form associations to provide alternative services such as fire fighting.
The two provisions allowing secession of states and individuals, respectively, would enhance just government in that as the government tends towards increased tyranny, which it must because of the greedy ones, individuals would withdraw. As the numbers of individuals who have withdrawn increases, the greedy ones would have ever less power. In their own greedy interest, the greedy ones would need to leave more liberties to the people, so that they would want to participate in the government.
This concept becomes the definition of just government. A just government is one that subjects itself and its agents to the two fundamental laws and that allows citizens and provinces to secede from the government without loss of personal freedoms or property.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
(1) The first law has been stated: "Love your neighbor as yourself." – Jesus, and also "Act only according to that maxim whereby you can at the same time will that it should become a universal law."– Lock
(2) The second law has been stated: "Thou shalt not bear false witness." - Exodus 20:16.
Labels:
greedy politicians,
just government,
lust for power,
secede,
two laws,
tyranny
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
